Review
Mozart, Mahler shine in concert
By
Glenn Pillsbury
Special to
The Record
November
17, 2007 6:00 AM
Two visions of Vienna more than a century
apart came together in an enjoyable and successful concert Thursday as
the Stockton Symphony closed the first half of its 2007-08 season. The
program will be repeated tonight at Atherton Auditorium.
The performance paired the classical style
of Mozart's well-known Symphony No. 40 with the romanticism of
Mahler's Symphony No. 4. The first work was written in 1788, the
second in 1901, and if the music produced in the intervening years has
made it difficult for modern audiences to link the two, the symphony's
balanced execution helped re-establish the connection.
Conductor Peter Jaffe took the Mozart at a
very brisk tempo overall, which worked nicely for the two outer
movements but gave the two inner movements a bit of a perfunctory
feel. The rhythmic precision so characteristic of Mozart's day was
also well done in the outer movements but less so in the inner ones,
at times sounding muddy. Still, the low strings performed with
surprising finesse and energy in the last movement's highly virtuosic
sections.
Mahler's heavyweight reputation is belied
here by the subtle grace of his fourth symphony. His usual propensity
for massive structures, performing forces and overall length is
moderated as well. While the work lasts nearly an hour, Jaffe and the
orchestra easily led the listener along its path.
Filled with a variety of small-instrument
groupings and melodies, the opening two movements got things off to an
engaging start. The winds had much of the say here, with clarinetist
Erin Finkelstein, flutist Johanna Borenstein and oboist Kyle Bruckmann
creating an elegant blend and jaunty texture. Even the rarely heard
contrabassoon got into the act, with Lawrence Rhodes providing some
extreme low end.
The emotional weight of the symphony lies in
its third movement, one of Mahler's favorites. Jaffe's command of the
opening carefully shaped the haunting pathos of the cellos' line, and
as the intense texture built up through successive entries by the
violas and second violins, the inevitable arrival of the first violins
into the whirl produced the evening's most astonishing and beautiful
music.
With so much already in the mix, the
appearance of soprano Aimée Puentes in the symphony's final movement
topped off the emotional journey. Puentes was in fine voice
throughout, and her handling of the movement's gentler chordal
passages contained just the right amount of expressive dissonance with
the orchestra to remind us of the text's underlying humanity.
Contact Glenn Pillsbury at
features@recordnet.com.
|