By
Glenn Pillsbury
Special to the Record
November 18, 2006 6:00 AM
In 1926, Manlio Silva
took a risk and started the Stockton Symphony. Eighty years later,
the orchestra is still taking risks, as evidenced by Thursday's
concert at Atherton Auditorium. The program will be repeated
today.
The concert opened
with the world premiere of a work written for the symphony by
Stockton's Max Simoncic. "Juxtapose" draws on a poem by fellow San
Joaquin Delta College instructor Michael Duffett titled "A
Celebration of Stockton."
In recognition of the
piece's significance as a symphony showpiece, Simoncic gave each
member plenty to do. The continuous hustle and bustle, however,
left few chances for reflection or an exploration of anything
deeper.
Simoncic opened the
work with an episode of tight counterpoint for the strings and
contrasted it later with a dense rhythmic drive. The piece also
featured a surprising amount of virtuosic piano writing, which was
well played by Esther Kemalyan Roche and at times verged on
becoming a piano concerto.
With an expert tone
and impressive breath control, William Bennett's performance of
Mozart's Oboe Concerto in C major offered an interesting
counterpoint to the modern music preceding it.
A relatively new
work, given that it was written in 1777 and then lost until the
1970s, its outer two movements danced and weaved with a enjoyable
grace. Here Bennett was clearly at ease, floating through the
orchestra's accompaniment with confident precision. Alas, not even
that could save the deadening effect of the piece's middle
movement.
Performers in
previous centuries were expected to use the cadenza sections of
movements to demonstrate their abilities at improvisation. This
risky practice became very rare over the past century as a canon
of great cadenzas was usually trotted out.
Bennett's decision to
revisit the practice of improvised cadenzas introduced a welcome
element to a performance already brimming with personality.
Indeed, in a humorous gesture of oboe solidarity, Bennett even
inserted his own short oboe trio into the third-movement cadenza,
sharing the spotlight with symphony oboists Kyle Bruckmann and
Rebecca Secor in a light-hearted tweak of the notion of soloist as
individual hero.
Composing music is
always a risky endeavor, but in the best cases, risk brings great
rewards. Tchaikovsky's Symphony No. 6 in B minor is an example of
a risk that paid off, both for the composer and the symphony.
In this work,
Tchaikovsky departed from the conventional form of the symphony
for dramatic effect. Conducting from memory, Jaffe gave his full
attention to shaping each of the melodies that are the essence of
the symphony. The orchestra responded with a sound that remained
balanced and cohesive, resulting in a solid performance.
Contact Glenn
Pillsbury at
features@recordnet.com